balivillacareWhat a Bali villa nets its owner Ask about your villa

Notes

Compare Two Bali Villa Managers: 5 Questions, Same 20% Fee

Written from primary sources · Editor-reviewed · Last changed 2026-09-21
By the balivillacare.com editorial team · Published 2026-09-20 · Last changed 2026-09-21 · 8 min read
7 primary sources cited on this page. How we check what is on this site

Key points

  • Two published Bali rate cards both say 20%. One lists housekeeping, laundry and pool maintenance inside the fee; the other states that staff salaries are not included in any of its plans.
  • The excluded line has a statutory floor. Badung's 2026 minimum wage is IDR 3,791,002.57 per month, and an employer adds 10.24–11.74% on top of the wage for social insurance.
  • That puts one directly employed worker at roughly USD 236–239 a month at the floor. A three-person villa is around USD 717 a month that the 20% does not cover.
  • Compare what reaches your account, not what leaves it. The five questions below are the comparison; the percentage is not.

Something worth saying before the criticism: the Bali villa management market publishes its prices. Openly, on public pages, with no form in front of them. That is better disclosure than several industries that consider themselves more professional.

Which makes it more interesting, not less, that two companies publishing the same number are selling materially different things — and that the difference has a floor set by Indonesian law, so it can be priced rather than argued about.

Both pages say 20%. Only one says what is in it.

What one rate card puts inside the fee

One operator prices villa management from 20% per booking, calculated on booking revenue, with no lock-in contract and no setup fee. Its inclusions list covers listing optimisation across platforms, 24/7 guest communication, dynamic pricing, housekeeping and laundry, pool maintenance and repairs, and monthly financial reporting. The page adds that there are no separate setup, listing or photography fees stacked on top.

What the other one puts outside it

A second operator’s public pricing page sets out two plans. The higher one is 20% of rental income, described as a complete, high-end solution for owners who want full professional management: operations, staff recruitment, training and supervision, personalised check-in and check-out, concierge, professional photography.

Further down the same page:

“Staff salaries are not included in any of our management plans and remain the responsibility of the villa owner.”

That is not buried and it is not dishonest. It is printed on the pricing page. The company is telling you exactly what it does, which is managing the staff rather than paying them — two genuinely different services that are easy to hear as one.

The same four rate cards, as a grid

Line item Marketing-only, 10% Full, 18% Full, 20% (A) Full, 20% (B)
Platform listings and optimisation yes yes yes yes
Guest communication yes yes yes yes
Dynamic pricing yes yes yes yes
Monthly financial reporting yes yes yes yes
Tax calculation and reporting yes not stated not stated yes
Housekeeping and laundry no not itemized inside the fee not stated
Pool and garden maintenance no not itemized inside the fee not stated
Staff recruitment and supervision no not stated not stated yes
Staff salaries no not stated not stated stated as excluded
Professional photography no not stated no separate fee yes
Setup / listing fee not stated none none not stated
Lock-in contract not stated none none not stated

“Not stated” is doing real work in that table. It is not a criticism of anyone — a rate card is an advertisement, not a schedule — but every “not stated” is a question you are going to have to ask, and the answers are what you are actually comparing.

The excluded line has a floor, and Indonesian law sets it

Until this point the argument is qualitative: one plan includes staff, another does not. What makes it decidable is that the excluded item is not a vague “extra”. It is employment, and employment in Indonesia has a published minimum.

The statutory floor per worker

Minimum wages in Bali are set per regency, which is the same axis that already decides which tax office your villa answers to. For 2026 the figures are IDR 3,791,002.57 per monthreported in Badung — where Seminyak, Canggu and Uluwatu sit — against IDR 3,316,798.48 per month in Gianyar and IDR 3,499,878.78 per month in Denpasar.

These are floors, not wages. A villa manager in Seminyak is not paid the minimum, and anyone reading these as “what staff cost” has read them wrong. What they establish is the number below which the arrangement cannot legally go.

What an employer adds on top of the wage

The wage is not the cost of employing somebody. On top of it, an employer in Indonesia contributes 10.24–11.74% of the monthly wage to social insurance: work accident cover, death cover, old-age savings and pension to BPJS Ketenagakerjaan, plus health cover at 4% under Presidential Regulation 64 of 2020. The worker’s own deductions are separate and are not in that figure.

Put those together at the Badung floor and one directly employed worker is roughly USD 236 to USD 239 a month, converted at IDR 17,745 per USD.

What that does to a “20%” plan

A villa with three staff — someone running it, someone cleaning it, someone on the pool and garden — is around USD 717 a month at the floor, and that is the number sitting outside the 20%.

On the model this site publishes, a villa grossing USD 6,000 a month nets USD 2,472 where staffing sits inside the commission. Move the same payroll outside it and the owner nets USD 1,755. Same villa, same gross, same advertised percentage. For comparison, the management commission itself on that villa is USD 1,080.

⚠️ Two caveats that matter. These are statutory floors rather than market pay, so a real payroll is higher. And whether your arrangement makes you the employer — rather than the management company, or an agency — is a question for an Indonesian adviser who has read your contract, not one a website can answer. What is not in doubt is that somebody is the employer, and that the cost exists whichever answer applies.

Why the percentage is the wrong comparison

The fee is one of six deductions

The management commission is one of six things that happen between the rate a guest pays and the transfer that reaches an owner’s account. The others are the platform’s commission, the regional accommodation tax, the channel manager and payment processing, the actual cost of running the villa plus any markup on it — and then the owner’s own income tax. The full walk is set out line by line, and the platform layer alone is comparable in size to the whole management commission — with Airbnb the only one of the three major platforms that publishes its rate at all.

Two 20% offers can differ by more than 20% differs from 18%

That is the finding, and it is the reason “what percentage do you charge” is a weaker opening question than it feels like. Three separate mechanisms can move more money than two points of commission:

  • whether staff sit inside the fee, worth roughly USD 5,664 to USD 11,472 a year at the floor for two to four people;
  • whether third-party costs are rebilled at cost or cost plus;
  • what your channel mix looks like, because the same booking is worth different amounts depending on where it came from.

Which fee model suits which villa works through the first of those, and the contract clauses work through the second. If the words themselves are the confusing part — management, property management, rental management, caretaker — the terms are compared side by side here.

The five questions, and what the answers sound like

Ask A good answer sounds like A weak answer sounds like
What is the commission calculated on — gross booking value, or what is left after the platform? “Gross booking value, defined in Schedule 1.” “Rental income.” (undefined, and the definition is theirs)
Are villa staff salaries inside the fee? “No — here is the current monthly figure for a villa of your size.” “We handle the staff.” (handling is not paying)
Are third-party costs rebilled at cost or cost plus? “At invoiced cost, and you can see the supplier invoices.” “We get good rates.” (not the question)
Which platforms, at what commission on each? “These four, at these rates — I can show you in the extranet.” “All the major ones.”
Can I see a specimen monthly statement? An actual statement, with the other owner’s details removed. A sample layout, or a promise to send one later.

Ask two companies the same five and write down the answers. The spread between the answers will be wider than the spread between the percentages, and unlike the percentages it tells you what you are buying.

What to do with the answers

Nothing adversarial. Every one of these five is answerable in a day by a company doing the job properly, and most of them from a system they already have open. The value is not in the answers themselves — it is in which of the five produces a delay.

If you already let the villa, the fastest version of this is to run your own gross and your own net through the model before you speak to anyone. An enquiry that arrives with a specific disagreement attached is a different conversation from one that arrives with a name.

Sources cited on this page

  1. Villa Management Bali — published pricing plans
  2. Balitecture — published villa management rate
  3. Airbnb — Service fees
  4. BPJS Ketenagakerjaan — contribution rates for wage earners
  5. Perpres No. 64 Tahun 2020, Pasal 30 — health contribution split
  6. Keputusan Gubernur Bali No. 1021/03-M/HK/2025 — 2026 minimum wages, as reported
  7. Bank Indonesia — JISDOR USD/IDR reference rate

Every figure above links to the source it was read from. This page was last changed on 21 September 2026. How we check this.

All posts · Yield estimator · Bali villa management fees

Unsure of your own numbers?

Tell us which part of Bali the villa is in. Five questions, and your details are the last step.

Ask about what your villa nets

Five quick questions. Your details are the last step, never the first.

Step 1 of 6
Where are you up to with the villa?

This decides whether the useful conversation is about an existing statement or about a building that does not have guests in it yet.

What do you actually want to know?

There is no wrong answer. It is the difference between wanting a statement read and wanting a company replaced, and those are different pieces of work.

How big is the villa?

Bedroom count is the single strongest driver of both the rate you can charge and the staffing the villa needs.

How is the villa held?

This is not a trick question and you can skip it. It decides which accommodation classification the villa can be licensed under, which is the first thing any competent company will ask you.

What do you have in front of you?

An owner holding twelve months of statements and an owner holding nothing are asking the same question with very different evidence, and the second conversation starts somewhere else.

Where should they reach you?

This is the only step that asks for personal details.

By clicking “Send my enquiry” I agree that balivillacare.com may pass the details above to up to three villa management companies covering my area of Bali, when any are taking enquiries, so that they can contact me about managing or reviewing my villa by email, phone or message. Consent is not a condition of anything — every page, table and calculator on this site is free to use without it. You can withdraw consent at any time by replying to any message you receive, or by writing to contact@balivillacare.com. We are not a villa management company, we do not manage or let property, and sending this does not appoint anyone to do anything.

  • Your details go only to companies covering your area, when one is taking enquiries — never to more than three
  • Free to you — the only fee we accept is a fixed amount per enquiry, agreed in advance
  • Any fee is the same whether you sign with anyone or not

Your enquiry is ready to send

Here is what happens after you submit:

  1. Your answers go only to villa management companies covering your area, when one is taking enquiries.
  2. At most three may ever contact you, and only through the details you gave.
  3. You decide who, if anyone, you speak to. You are committed to nothing.

We are not a villa management company and we do not manage or let property. Any fee we take is the same fixed amount whether or not you sign with anyone.

Free enquiryFive questions · no obligation Start now